Roxanne
Directed by Fred Schepisi
Written by Edmond Rostand, Steve Martin
Starring Steve Martin, Darryl Hannah, Damon Wayans, Shelley Duvall
Release Date June 19th, 1987
The Steve Martin-Darryl Hannah comedy "Roxanne" celebrated its 30th anniversary recently, prompting a nostalgic rewatch for many. As a child, the film was a source of endless laughter, but revisiting it as an adult revealed its flaws. The experience was underwhelming, leaving a sense of disappointment.
Similarly, revisiting Martin's 1980 standup comedy special, "In Honor of Steve," highlighted a disconnect from his earlier work. This isn't to say that Martin lacks comedic talent or that his work is universally unfunny; it's a matter of personal taste and how humor evolves over time. What was once hilarious now falls flat.
A prime example of this disconnect is the opening scene of "Roxanne," a fight scene meant to showcase C.D. Bales' sensitivity about his large nose. The scene feels awkward and forced, failing to establish C.D.'s character effectively, especially considering it's the audience's introduction to him.
The film is filled with instances of excessive physical comedy, often at the expense of character development and narrative cohesion. One example occurs after the pivotal scene where C.D., disguised as Chris, confesses his love to Roxanne. Despite the emotional weight of the scene, the film abruptly shifts into a jarring and unfunny physical comedy routine. This unnecessary addition disrupts the narrative flow and undercuts the emotional impact of the scene. Martin's physical antics, while perhaps amusing to some, detract from the film's overall effectiveness.
While "Roxanne" has its moments of charm, and Steve Martin shares undeniable chemistry with the main characters, particularly Darryl Hannah, there are glimpses of untapped potential. The meet-cute scene, for instance, is genuinely delightful. Martin's wit shines through, and the scene exudes charm. Had the film maintained this focus on wit and clever dialogue instead of relying on slapstick humor, "Roxanne" could have been a standout romantic comedy of the 1980s.
Ultimately, it's the failure to capitalize on this potential that diminishes the film's appeal. "Roxanne" is a flawed film with moments of charm. It's mediocre, occasionally bordering on creepy, and while it has its moments, it could have been so much more. The film's shortcomings highlight the importance of balance and restraint in comedy, as well as the need to adapt humor to evolving tastes and sensibilities.
